Green Mountain Grill Vs Traeger – Which Pellet Grill To Choose

Do you wish you could grill meat or vegetables all year round? Having problems with uneven grilling? Sounds like you are ready for pellet grills.

This next phase in smoking meat is designed to make it possible for everyone to get perfectly grilled meat, every time. The trend that was once thought of as being nothing more than a passing fad, has proved to be quite popular. Unlike traditional gas and charcoal barbecuing, pellet grills have made grilling almost too easy.

Read on to find my top pick in this this epic green mountain grill vs traeger pellet grill comparison.

Models In This Head To Head:

Two of the main competitors in this market are Traeger and Green Mountain grills (GMG).

In this article, we'll be looking at the difference between two of the top selling models The Traeger Grills Lil Texas Elite 22 and the Green Mountain Davy Crocket Pellet Grill (both available on Amazon).

But before we get into the nitty gritty of Green Mountain grills vs Traeger grills, it's probably a great idea to understand the benefits of pellet grilling, and why you might want to consider it.

What is Pellet Grilling And How Does A Pellet Grill Work?

It’s no secret. Smoking meat with wood enhances taste. Pellet smokers implement pellet-burning technology. The technology allows for better precision in temperature control. Made of natural hardwood pressed into a pellet, the pellets are poured into a smoker’s hopper. A computerized system that regulates temperature can be set similar to an oven.

Temperature remains constant as it is regulated by the system which turns an auger to drop pellets into the fire pot as required, keeping temperatures under control. Temperature normally ranges between 170 - 550 degrees F. Fans in grills then circulate heat evenly.

Moreover, by turning the heat up you can grill anything from burgers, hotdogs, pizzas to steaks. Baking is also possible. For cooks that require varying temperatures, such as a brisket, the grill enables users to change temperatures at will. You can set your grill to smoke, turn it up to sear and lower it later to keep it warm.

Here's a handy graphic to explain the process further:

How Does A Pellet Grill Work - diagram and explanation

Why Should You Consider Pellet Grills?

Grilling has long been synonymous with healthy cooking. Vegetables tend to retain most of their nutrients, meats shed off excess fat and foods lock in both taste and moisture. The end result is a healthier, better tasting meal.

Smoking or barbecuing is however shunned upon due to its difficulty. Not only does it take years to master, but also requires a lot of preparation before hand and monitoring.

Pellet grilling is much easier. With a few button presses, a turn of a knob and you are well on your way to a world class grilled meal. 

Probably one of the main highlights of pellet grilling, is the smoke flavor infusion. With a wide range of pellets to choose from, the pellets leave your meat with an authentic smoker taste. Pellet options include:

Green Mountain Pellet Smoker Grill Review

The Green Mountain Grills Davy Crockett Pellet Grill, available on Amazon, incorporates a side mounted pellet hopper onto a cooking chamber. The hopper’s capacity is about 17 LBS. Rotating at speeds of 4.7 to 5.2 RPMs, the auger is managed by an electrically powered (110v) control unit.

The grill has a temperature range of between 170 to 500 degrees F. Temperatures can be adjusted in 5 degree increments for the Daniel Boone version.

Additionally, the inbuilt fan promotes combustion of the pellets. It also improves circulation of heat, leaving your meal evenly cooked. Further, the positive pressure fan can keep dreaded auger fires away by ensuring there are no sparks.

Besides the above mentioned features, other features of note include a hopper alarm. Incase pellet supply runs low, a built in alarm goes off. To get things going on the coldest of days, the cold weather booster feature facilitates

Suggested pellets for the grill include GMG’s premium FruitBlend, Premium Gold pellets, and their Premium Texas Blend.

The GMG is Wi-Fi enabled. With a choice of using an iOS or Android app, users can regulate temperatures, check up on cooking conditions and a host of other settings. By emitting a Wi-Fi signal, smartphones can connect to it in point-to-point mode, through the Green Mountain Grill servers or through the home Wi-Fi network. Having a host of LEDs, your grill will helpfully inform you which mode you are using when connecting to it.

What the feature list fails to show, is the reliability of the grill. Based on customer reviews, the GMG hardly breaks down in regular use. With a body built from 14 gauge steel and a 13 gauge steel lid, the grill feel robust and and can take a few knocks.

Green Mountain Grills Davy Crockett Pellet Grill – WIFI enabled

Traeger Pellet Smoker Grill Review

Treager pellet grills like the Lil Tex Elite 22, which I'll be discussing in this article, are well made, reliable, and extremely popular. This short video offers a fab overview of these grills, and how to begin pellet cooking.

Traeger has been a pioneer in the pellet grills field since the 80s. Traeger welcomed us to a world of grilling without gas or charcoal. Though the company has been in the market the longest, most customers concur that their grills do not always hold the best value for your hard earned buck.

Nonetheless, they offer a well rounded range for every budget and occasions, with the Lil Tex Elite 22 Wood Pellet Grill and smoker being a bestseller on Amazon.

Technologywise, these grills remain similar to GMG grills. A controlled number of pellets are fed via an auger to a firepot, ignited and kept under control.

Circulated air distributes heat evenly in the cooking chamber.

The Traeger Lil' Tex Elite 22 offers amazing versatility, allowing you to barbecue, braise, bake, smoke, roast and grill. Cook time and temperature control are at your fingertips, cook hot and fast or slow and low, barbecue cooking was never this simple.

As for pit temp control, versions such as the Traeger Pro Series 22, with a dial thermostat starts at 180 degrees F and maxes out at 375 degrees F. This is at increments of 25 degrees F.

Traeger has a wide range of wood pellets to flavor you smoke. From classics such as hickory and mesquite to more exotic flavors such as Trager's rendition, turkey.

Traeger TFB42LZBC Grills Lil Tex Elite 22 Wood Pellet Grill and Smoker - Grill, Smoke, Bake, Roast, Braise, and BBQ (Bronze)

Overall Winner

Our green mountain grill vs traeger grill comparison would be incomplete without picking an overall winner.

Reasons For Picking The Green Mountains Grill Over The Treager Grill

Based on the green mountain grill's perfomance, I found it better for the following reasons:

#1 - GMG’s Venturi styled firepot, styled after the Venturi carburator ensures complete combustion. This makes for a clear burn and a cleaner smoke. Good quality smoke is essential in imparting flavor to your meat.

#2 - Unlike traditional grills, GMG provides an extra 4 inches on its peaked lid design. This makes cooking a stand up chicken possible.

#3 - Each GMG grill comes with a retractable side tray table. This provides pitmasters with an all-together, much needed working area. Essential for tail-gates, as you try finding space to apply your favorite rubs.

#4 - GMG grills have better temperature control intervals. Ability to change temperatures at 5 degree F intervals offers better control over your pit than at 25 degree F. If using the phone app instead, you can actually achieve 1 degree F intervals. Customers also report much less temperature fluctuations than when using Trager grills.

#5 - The GMG stainless steel grease tray can slide open and close. In its open position, it allows for flames to sear you cuts of meat.

#6 - Built using quality stainless steel, GMG models have a reassuring heft. Traeger evenly matches GMG in terms in weight. Pricewise, GMG still manages to beat Traeger by a mile, especially for their base (Non-WiFi) models.

#7 - Going over customer reviews, it is evident that GMG suffers far less returns on purchases. Not to worry though. Traeger has excellent customer service who always assist when faulty parts crop up.

No matter how you cut it, the technology is here to stay. Erring is almost an impossibility with these grills. Equipped with a Green Mountain pellet grill temperature probe, all you have to watch for is the right internal temperature.

For their versatility, reliability and ease of use, both these pellet grills are excellent value for money, and are set to make charcoal and gas grills obsolete.

Happy pellet grilling folks!

1 thought on “Green Mountain Grill Vs Traeger – Which Pellet Grill To Choose”

  1. Steve, thank you for a great comparison of smokers. I am brand new to smokers and trying to read up on it. I have seen comments that Traeger is now manufacturing in China. Are you aware of this and is it accurate? Thanks again.


Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.